The Medical Devices Agency provides a summary of the properties of instrument and equipment disinfectants4. The information below provides some brief pointers.
Gluteraldehyde 2%
Gluteraldehyde 2% has a broad range of microbial activity even under moderate soiling conditions. It is no longer commonly used in clinical practice. Its use is strictly controlled under COSHH Regulations8. The Health and Safety Executive has set maximum exposure limits for gluteraldehyde9. This is generally now being withdrawn due to adverse affects on the health of staff.
Ortho-phthalaldehyde (Cidex OPA)
Cidex OPA is a high-level disinfectant with reduced exposure time. It requires no activation and is a clear, pale-blue liquid which contains 0.55% OPA. It has a broad range of microbial activity and requires shorter exposure times than gluteraldehyde10. It can be an irritant, which may affect the skin, eyes, throat and lungs of health workers who come into contact with it and as such should be used under COSHH Regulations8. A Medical Device Alert was issued in 2004 about the risk of hypersensitivity in some patients with a history of bladder cancer having repeated cystoscopy where urological instruments have been reprocessed using Cidex OPA11.
Peracetic acid 0.2 to 0.35%
Peracetic acid is a useful alternative to gluteraldehyde as it is less toxic. It also has a broad range of microbial activity even under moderate soiling conditions. However, it is not as stable as gluteraldehyde and it may be slightly corrosive or damaging.
Alcohol
Alcohol, usually in the form of 70% isopropyl alcohol or 60 to 80% ethyl alcohol (ethanol), is available as a liquid or impregnated into alcohol wipes or swabs. Alcohol is rapidly active against most bacteria and viruses, but it is not sporicidal and has poor penetration. Therefore, its main use is for rapidly disinfecting clean surfaces (e.g. dressing trolleys, scissors) and for wiping over electrical equipment that you cannot clean by immersion methods. The alcohol evaporates quickly to leave surfaces dry. As alcohol is flammable, you cannot use it in large amounts (e.g. in a chemical washer-disinfector).
Peroxygen compounds
Peroxygen compounds have no sporicidal activity and have poor activity against mycobacteria. They are non-irritant at in-use concentrations. However, they are corrosive to some metals. You should only consider using these compounds where the risk of infection from tolerant organisms is low.
Chlorine releasing agents (> 1000 ppm available chlorine)
Chlorine releasing agents have a broad range of antimicrobial activity. The most commonly used agents are sodium hypochlorite (NaOCl) and sodium dichlorisocyanurate (NaDCC). They are useful in decontaminating blood and body fluid spills and have a wide range of environmental applications (e.g. disinfecting worktops, patient supports, mattresses, heat labile linen, baths, toilets and sinks). However, hypochlorite can damage and bleach many fabrics and causes pitting of metal. Organic matter inactivates chlorine releasing agents, so high concentrations are required for direct application to spills or grossly contaminated surfaces. Tablet forms have a longer shelf life than liquid formats. Dilutions of chlorine releasing agents are unstable (they become ineffective within 24 hours), so you must always use a freshly prepared solution. You must not mix these agents with hot water, acids or urine, as a rapid release of irritating chlorine may occur.
Clear soluble phenolics 0.6 to 2%
Clear soluble phenolics have no sporicidal activity and no activity against non-enveloped viruses. Activity against enveloped viruses is poor. However, they are active against bacteria, even in the presence of moderate soiling. You can use them for general environmental disinfection and for disinfecting body fluid spills (particularly faeces and sputum). They are not suitable for clearing blood spills due to their poor viricidal activity.
Quaternary ammonium compounds
The antimicrobial activity of quaternary ammonium compounds varies with the concentration of the product. However, they generally have poor antimicrobial activity and organic matter inactivates them. You should only consider using these compounds where the risk of infection from tolerant organisms is low.
Chlorine dioxide
Chlorine dioxide has similar properties to peracetic acid. It has a broad spectrum of activity and is rapidly sporicidal and is active against non-sporing bacteria, including mycobacteria and viruses at 150 and 350ppm. It is potentially corrosive but commercial preparations contain an inhibitor12-14.
Superoxidised water
Superoxidised water is generated at the point of use and is the product of the electrolysis of salt solution (NaCl). The solution collected from the anode or positive terminal, contains a mixture of radicals with strong oxidising properties. It is highly effective as a disinfectant and rapidly destroys spores, mycobacteria, fungi and viruses14. The user hires the disinfector, which is placed close to the endoscope washer-disinfector. The generator criteria are critical to efficacy and are microprocessor controlled and if not met, generation will stop.